Math IV - Monkey see, monkey do

This week I had the opportunity to participate in a webinar that discussed the concept of open ended questions. What is an open ended question you ask? Well, let me first ask you this: 


(please provide your answer in the comment section)

This is a great example of an open ended question. It has some of these key features:
- There is no one right answer
- It allows for all types of learners to approach the question differently
- It allows students to provide reasoning to their answers

I especially like that this question allows for students to consider things that aren't necessarily math related. For example, a student might consider:
- The neighbourhood demographic (does everyone give out candy at Halloween?)
- Are the homes close together?
- Is their sibling old enough/motivated enough to go to as many houses as possible?

I imagine that young students would get very creative with their answers. The questions also promote discussion, which is usually lacking in a Math classes. It provides students with the opportunity to explain their reasoning and potentially convince their peers that their method makes sense. This is beneficial for a class because it promotes collaboration while simultaneously improving oral communication skills. 

A downside to these questions is that they usually aren't focused on one specific mathematical skill. Meaning a teacher who is very focused on always teaching from the curriculum may see the questions as a waste of time. Perhaps this is evidence that the math curriculum is too dense in content. Which brings me to my next point, which is teaching to memorize versus teaching to learn. 

If teachers are strictly focused on teaching from the curriculum (a.k.a. doing their job), I fear units will be rushed and authentic learning will be replaced by memorization. I think math minds need to develop some new innovative ways to test students that force students to do more than just memorize. I believe that anyone can learn, but not everyone can memorize. And memorization doesn't validate intelligence. Consider the video below. I would suggest that the college graduate who took the test is more intelligent than the chimp, however based on the test his working memory isn't as strong.



If we want to develop students that can think for themselves we need to provide them with opportunities to do so. Otherwise we might just create a real Planet of the Apes!

via GIPHY


Comments

  1. Hi James,

    I feel extremely flattered that you used one of my open-ended questioning examples from my webinar! To answer the question: I would choose $1 per house in 4 hours based on how I remember trick-or-treating when I was little - I would RUN to as many houses as possible before my parents would say it was time to go home. I know I would have been convinced as a child that I could exceed 75 houses. My answer demonstrates how most kids would probably problem-solve and strategize when given an open-ended question - they would do it based on their personal experiences, rather than on mathematical reasoning and proving. Therefore, in order to successfully implement open-ended questioning in the classroom, the teacher would have to spend a lot of time demonstrating how to efficiently answer an open-ended question, to ensure that students are still using mathematics in their problem-solving.

    Have a wonderful week!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey James!

    You brought up a lot of great points in your post. I strongly believe that teachers should incorporate more open-ended questions in their math lessons opposed to only asking questions that result in a definite answer. Students need to be able to see the "big picture" and learn to think out of the box. Students who simply memorize steps and equations will be clueless when posed with mathematical problems in the real world. Asking open-ended question is a great strategy to get students to problem solve and think on their own without leaning back on what they have memorized.

    Thanks for sharing :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi James!

    Thanks for sharing such an interesting blog post. The open ended question above is also a great way to boost student confidence in math since the questions provide an entry point for students of all strengths. When answering the question, there are a lot of factors to consider. Those factors could lead to either one being the correct answer. Personally, I would opt for the $1 a house because I am hoping to get through as many houses as possible. I would also look at a map to choose a densely populated neighbourhood to cover as many houses as possible.

    I agree with your point about teachers focusing on memorization vs. understanding big ideas. When I was in school, I missed out on seeing all the connections between the big ideas because teachers focused on getting us to memorize all the small steps. As future educators it seems like it is our duty to provide rich tasks that give students the opportunity to explore these mathematical concepts.

    Thanks for sharing the post!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi James,

    I really enjoyed reading your blog post this week, you bring up a lot of great points. I particularly like the stance you took on this weeks blog by connecting the webinar you watched to the modules. The open ended question you provided is a great way for students to learn how to represent an answer in different ways that does not involve defined steps and procedures. Questions such as this help students to think outside of the box in order to make math make sense to them.

    I also think a teacher could target certain open ended questions to specific units. The questions might not always neatly fit into a specific expectation, but like you said, maybe that's not for the best? The question you provided I think could even relate to a probability unit- which scenario provides you with the better probability of more money?

    Great post James, thanks for sharing!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hey James,

    Awesome post! I loved reading it and watching the video you included. I love all the connections that your blog post has for this week. I can specifically relate to the concept of open questions. Unfortunately, I do not remember as a student being able to answer a question differently from my teacher. There was only and always one right answer and I somehow could never get it. By provide our students with open ended questions it allows them to foster growth mindset, increase creativity and encourage them to think about math in a totally different way. As future educators it is our job to create a welcoming classroom full of open-ended questions, this will allow for students to explore ideas and topics that would never have been allowed in the fixed classroom setting. Terrific job this week!
    Cheers, Courtney

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Math VI - It's the Final Countdown (PUN INTENDED)

Math I