Math VI - It's the Final Countdown (PUN INTENDED)

Well ladies and gentlemen, this is it. My final entry into my Math Blog. I have to say it's a bittersweet feeling.

Over these past 6 weeks, we've discussed topics from manipulatives to rich culminating tasks and everything in between. However, there is one very very very very important topic we've yet to discuss. A topic that you and I know well, or at least should by now. We discussed it in every single one of our courses thus far and for a moment I thought we might make it through this course without anyone uttering the words of it that shall not be named..


via GIPHY

Sorry Potter fans, I'm not talking about ol' parseltongued Voldemort. I'm taking about Assessment and Evaluation!

Although I make light of it in my introduction, assessment really is the key ingredient needed to support and improve student learning.

Recently, I've begun to listen to podcasts while walking my dog (really trying to maximize those learning hours!). I've come across a useful teaching podcast titled The Cult of Pedagogy. In a recent episode the host discussed the concept of completely eliminating grades from the classroom with a teacher who has done exactly that!

There were a few points that really stood out to me. The first is that she felt the student became more motivated to succeed. She believed that because she was giving honest purposeful feedback to each student, the students felt that she truly cared about them. In turn, this motivated the students because they didn't want to disappoint their teacher. The second was that she noticed more authentic learning taking place. Frequent conferencing, both in person and via tech resources, allowed the student the opportunity to revise their work. Revision lead to deeper learning. And this lead to better student engagement, as well as provided her with frequent assessment opportunities.

The podcast reinforced my belief of two things. One, purposeful assessment/feedback is crucial to student learning. And two, purposeful assessment/feedback is very hard. Imagine yourself in your first placement, writing purposeful feedback on every student's essay, test, presentation rubric, or whatever it may have been that you were assessing. It's incredibly time consuming and undoubtedly mentally exhausting.
There are a few tips to get around this (note, these student in her classroom were working on a summative project):
- Allot time for frequent check-ins, not one major check-in.
- Use tech as a resource, not all check-ins need to be face to face.
- Use your students as resources, if a student has mastered one stage of the assignment, have them become the 'expert' on that section. They can explain to others what was explained to them.
- Encourage your students to give themselves feedback first. They're usually bright enough to know where they fell short.
- IT IS HARD! But who ever said being a great teacher was easy? Just like any profession, it takes a combination of skill and work ethic to be great!

Do you think you could ever do away with grades? What strategies have you used in your classroom that offer your students purposeful feedback?


Here is a link to the podcast discussed above if you're interested:
https://www.cultofpedagogy.com/starr-sackstein/


Thanks for a great semester everyone!

Comments

  1. Hi James,

    I thought it was interesting that getting rid of grades makes students more motivated. By eliminating grades, students are left with feedback to let them know how their doing, and that feedback is great for all students to know where they are without having to worry about the letter grade. As a student who only looked at the grade if it was bad, I ignored the feedback. By getting rid of it, it now forces students to look at the feedback

    Really nice job!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey James,

    Your post really got me thinking of the positive effects of eliminating grades. I would definitely consider taking away grades with my future students. Receiving grades has way too many negative impacts on students such as bullying, conflict with parents, discouraging students, disregarding written feedback and categorizing students. My only concern is not receiving grades in elementary school may result in complications for high school where grades are necessary for career paths. Thanks for sharing the podcast, I will be sure to check it out next time I'm walking my dog!

    Good luck in Block 2 :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi James,

    Insightful post! In regards to your question, no, I do not think I could do away with grades within my own classroom. This might be surprising, as most people try to take the high road and immediately say they could for sure take away grades and focus strictly on descriptive feedback, however, I think we would be doing a dis-service to our students for when they enter the post-secondary world in the future. As we all know, post-secondary education relies heavily on grades, and because of the grades we receive in middle school and high school, we show up to our post-secondary school understanding exactly what the percentage means (49% and lower means you failed, 50% and higher means you passed).

    Have a great rest of your week!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hey James,

    First of all you caught my attention immediately as soon as I saw the picture of Lord Voldemort, (potterhead) over here! Second, what an intriguing blog post this week. I love how you perfectly summed up this weeks class as well as incorporated something that you enjoy from your everyday life (podcasts). I found the points of interest in the podcast very thought-provoking. I do not know if I could ever go without grades. Grades are the basis for accepting students into different university and college programs. They separate students and have been the building blocks for our education since, forever. However, descriptive feedback is something new and all the rage right now. In my placement last year I did my inquiry on descriptive feedback. I found that my students had never really been exposed to it and were still focused on their percentage during the beginning stages. However, as we got closer to the end of my time at the school the students started to value my commentary and I could see that they were taking my opinions and our discussions to heart. I do believe that assessment is about a healthy balance between descriptive feedback, levels and every once and a while a letter or percent grade. As future teachers we are in the era where we might dismantle the grading system and solely focus on descriptive feedback.... I'm unsure about how I feel. It should be interesting to see what the future holds! Awesome post this week.

    Cheers, Courtney

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hey James,

    I thought this was a really interesting subject to touch upon as a last blog post. The idea of removing grades and focus on a progressive feedback structure is something that I believe can be useful as a growth tool. At the end of the day, however, I believe a students grade is an accomplishment (or accountability) that the individual will feel they earned, whereas a teachers admiration (or lack thereof) may feel sometimes out of their control.

    It would be interesting to hear the unfiltered opinions of the students who participated in this program. Did they enjoy the idea having no grades because it meant that the work they did would have little bearing on a final outcome (regardless of disappointing the teacher)? Did the students give their honest feedback when asked what they thought of the program? Honesty can sometimes be harsh, and I think that may tie into not wanting to disappoint.

    While I don't believe I could ever do away with a marking system, I do think its a thought provoking idea that can be used to improve your feedback with students.

    Great post, thanks for sharing James!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Math I

Math IV - Monkey see, monkey do