Math IV - Different Strokes for Different Folks


Setting: In a mid-sized station wagon, a young girl is being driven by Dwayne 'The Rock' Johnson.


Little girl: Hey Dwayne, today in school we learned about 2-digit multiplication. 

Dwayne: Of very fun. I remember learning about that! 

Little girl: Let's see if you still remember how to solve them. What's 76 x 39?

Dwayne: Hmm. Let me just pull over so I can write this down. [Pulls car to roadside]

[Dwayne solves the equation using the following method:]



Little girl: That looks good Dwayne. Do you think there's another way to solve it?




END SCENE

Based on this scene, it seems that Dwayne 'The Rock' Johnson and myself have more in common than just our physiques. Similar to my experience, it seems Dwayne was only taught to solve 2-digit multiplication problems using 1 method and thus thinks it's the only way. However, as the little girl points out, there are actually a number of different methods that can be used to solve the same problem. Unfortunately, many teachers have seen some of these methods either and only teach what they know, which is likely the same method used in the scene (know as the traditional method). 
Here are some other methods that can be used to solve multiplication problems. Explanations can be found beneath each example. 

Lattice Method


Named after its crisscross structure, this is by far the most different method in comparison to the traditional method. The first step is to create the lattice box structure. You then place the factors (76 and 39) at the top and side of the lattice box. You then begin to pencil in the products of the smaller multiplication problems (e.g. 6 x 3 = 18). It's important to note that the 1 and 8 appear in different areas. Once all of the products have been penciled in, you use addition in the final step. In our first column (lower right), we have 4. In our second column, we have 8, 5 and 3, which add together to give us 16. In our third column we have 1, 1 and 6, which add together to give us 8 (*but we must add 1, because we need to carry over from the 16 in our second column). In our fourth column, we have 2. Finally, if we write down all of the numbers that we got from the columns (starting from the top right), we get 2 9 6 4, which is the correct answer! 

Box and Cluster Method


Similar to the Lattice method, this method also uses a box to create simpler multiplication problems. The first step is to create the box structure. You then must break down the factors into numbers that are easier to multiply (e.g. 76 is broken down into 70 and 6, 39 is broken down into 30 and 9). You then begin to pencil in the products of the more manageable multiplication problems (e.g. 30 x 6, 30 x 70, 9 x 70, and 9 x 6). Once you've solved for each box you begin the 'cluster' stage. The cluster stage is essentially an addition stage where you must add up the four products within the box (e.g. 2100 + 180 + 630 + 54). The sum is equal to 2964, which is the correct answer! 

Partial Products Method


This method is very similar to the Box and Cluster method. It is basically the exact same process, minus the box. The factors are broken down into more manageable equations. One these are solved, the products are added up. In this case, we get 2964, which is the correct answer! 

As you can see, there are many different ways to arrive to the same solution. To many, especially to those who were only taught the Traditional method, the other methods may seem bizarre or even look like a ridiculous waste of time. However, as teachers we need to be cognizant that our students may not learn the same way we do. What's easy for one person to understand may not be easy for another. This is why it's important to teach our students multiple methods to solving problems. By doing this, you're empowering the student to select a method that works best for them, as well as given them the best chance to succeed. It also offers a great opportunity to show your students that everyone is different and that no way of doing something is ever wrong. Were you taught to solve equations in different ways when you were in school?

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Math VI - It's the Final Countdown (PUN INTENDED)

Math I

Math IV - Monkey see, monkey do