Math II - You Can't Rush Art
It's paramount that students understand how mathematical concepts and equations work, but it's MORE important that they know the material so they can succeed on test, right..?
I believe that in today's math classes, far too much worth is allocated to the results and not the processes that lead to them. In order to alter this thought pattern, a significant change in the mathematic educational structure must be made. Before jumping into possible solutions, let's examine how we've gotten ourselves into this predicament. Consider the pressures on today's math teachers. Teachers feel pressure from the ministry to get through the curriculum. They feel pressure to achieve respectable marks in standardized tests like EQAO. They also feel responsible to adequately prepare their students for their proceeding academic years.
With all of these demands it's no wonder teachers can't focus on a student's understanding of material. They just hope that some of the material they teach is retained long enough to complete the unit's culminating task!
So what's the problem with this? Well, let's use an analogy to better illustrate what I believe to be happening in today's math classes. Imagine that a student's academic math career is similar to an automotive assembly line. The student is the car. The parts that are added on at each stage are the knowledge the student acquires year after year in mathematics. By the end of the assembly line, an efficient functioning car is the result. However, as recent EQAO results show, we're running into some major hiccups along the assembly line. By not ensuring that our students understand math concepts and equations, it's as though we're building the car with broken parts. Which is great if all we care about is producing a car that will get us from here to there for a few years. But why not focus on building a strong energy efficient vehicle that will last forever instead? A car that could be systematic...hydromatic...ultramatic...
via GIPHY
The problem is, a car like this can't be made with the parts we're using to build in math classrooms today. I believe we need to make some significant changes in math education. I'm not one to simply point out shortcomings without offering my own solutions on how to improve. However, I also won't claim to know the answer. Based on what I know, as well as what I've experienced as a student, we need to slow things down. Perhaps that means ridding ourselves of standardized tests. Or maybe simplifying the curriculum. If the ministry considers math so important, maybe math class sizes should be cut in half and additional teachers should be recruited. A subject like math is entirely scaffolded from grade 1 through 12, so if we can't expect consistent success if fundamentals are learned and understood well. *It's important to note that the issue at hand isn't as black and white as I've made it out to be. If it were, you can bet the assembly line would be fixed by now!
Let me leave you with some food for thought. Do you believe that anything worth teaching, is worth teaching well?
Lastly, this is what my friend says about art:
Let me leave you with some food for thought. Do you believe that anything worth teaching, is worth teaching well?
Lastly, this is what my friend says about art:
But math is different...right?
Hi James,
ReplyDeleteI absolutely LOVED your "Grease" reference. Made me laugh! And your automotive assembly line analogy is definitely accurate. In regards to standardized testing, I think that is one of the biggest mistakes our education system is making in regards to collecting data about the success of students in Language and Math. For example, this year, in most schools, EQAO is in May... that means grade 3 and 6 teachers are responsible for teaching (or should I say "rushing") the whole math and language curriculum before May, so that the students are "prepared" to write EQAO "successfully." Additionally, as future educators, we are told that open-ended questioning and inquiry is the secret to success, but this is contradicted through standardized testing, which doesn't make use of either.
Thanks for making me think today James!
Have a wonderful week.
Hey James!
ReplyDeleteI found what you said very interesting about how there is too much of a focus on the final product rather than the process. When I read this I think about how students tend to cheat. It is common knowledge that students cheat assuming they are getting the answer right based on whether the equation is solved correctly, however they neglect to learn the method on how that number is achieved. Cheating was a big problem with students who struggled with Math in my placement. In a grade 4 and 5 split class, students were so focused on getting a good grade that whether or not the knew how to do it seemed less important. It got to a point where we had to make different variations of the test, and inform the students so that we would have accurate diagnostics as to where students are in their mathematics levels.
Also, loved your references to Toy Story!! It's my favourite movie ever!
Great point!
Hey James,
ReplyDeleteI like the car analogy, and, well all of it. I might go further in a few areas, including the pressure on teachers by the students PARENTS. This is not the case everywhere, but for some it can be quite extreme. As for the car analogy, I find that there are often lapses in student understanding. In the case assembly line, you can have the parts (broken or not) which can be missed in the assembly process. On top of that, students often struggle with retaining the new math knowledge they've acquired, leading to further missing parts. By the "end" of the assembly, by the time you've put on the front bumper and the paint, the whole back end has fallen off. I agree that the curriculum needs to be fixed, but math teachers, ministers and parents and teachers, everyone, say that too. The question should be "Will we ever get it right?"
Great post!